![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Entry tags:
Star Trek and Justice League
Ok so - I have started watching The Orville and OMG *loves*
It's really strange, having The Orville and Discovery at the same time - like, the pilot for the Orville is a bit heavy and v sitcom-y and then literally the next episode they are into serious Star Trek like storylines, and like some heavy ones? The Orville is literally Star Trek: The Sitcom, or more accurately, Star Trek if it was real life. (Like TV military versus every story I have ever heard or experienced. (My great uncle is a now retired training officer in the RAF, Da was in the RAF, and I work in a museum that is part military. I have heard stories people)).
Discovery on the other hand, is Star Trek:Grey Area. On the subject of which, literally the next thing after my last Discovery post? That mid season finale....
Ok so - on the plus, Admiral didn't die! Wasn't dead. And she got to be awesome psych person (which feels a little bit like 'see this is what Deanna could have been' in some ways)
BUT STAMETS. *flails* - I saw it coming, from the semi bribery to effectively sacrifice himself for the scans (I half expected that whole conversation to be a weird half in Stamets head as he lay on a bio bed out of it version/POV of it) to oh look we showed you Lorca's screen and oh look Stamets is down.
I really really really hope he isn't dead. I really don't want ANOTHER kill all your gays storyline.
ESPECIALLY after we got the whole thing with Georgiou. Why? Because literally the three things that stood out in the pitch for this was: POC lead, Asian Woman Captain and Gay Character. We are already down Asian Woman Captain, and there's the dodgy, hopefully intential and to be dealt with thing that Lorca, white guy, is getting away with so much treason, while Michael, POC, is still being dragged for almost treasoning.
*sighs* It keeps having a built to being good, and then they throw in another 'look how messed up Lorca is!' moment.
And in other things, as kinda expected, the suspicions over Ash are likely correct (though the writers prob think they got that one past us) - I wasn't sure about the klingon disguised thing....but I was thrown by the 'hey I picked this guy up and now he's our new security chief!' thing. Though Lorca seems to just randomly adopt people he thinks are interesting so.....
Have to see how the back end of the series goes when it's back.
Non spoilery - I went to see Justice League - it's not bad. I still like Affleck's Batman. The others got a pretty good intro, but there was some weird bits (watch for Diana randomly changing from practical flat shoes to insane heels mid scene - and acquiring a sexy shawl, randomly) - but honestly? Not knowing what was changed by Whedon (though I would guess that extra sexy in scenes with Batman inconsistancies may be his addition) I don't know how much he changed the actual film.
It does work. It's an interesting story, it has pretty good pacing. It develops them all to an extent. It gives glimpses of things, and carries things to hint at links in and out (for solo films)
I could see bits that were v Joss and I could see gaps in the storytelling (I have seen enough Synder films to know his type of storytelling, and it had fragments of what he frames as key things, but others were left hanging a little).
The amazons costume change does not make sense at all (like one of the ladies who plays them was all 'you can see more of my muscles and it was more comfortable' and they argued some of it is ye olde amazons who didn't know how to make armour then, but seriously, I just went to a talk about the Scythians, and I studied Ancient Warfare, that be rubbish folks. Everyone has always been aware of what you need to protect. Plus the worst costumes were actually the modern ones (so 100 years AFTER we last saw them, they decided to reduce their armour, on the people who actually had the job that entails a threat *face palm*) To be honest, if the decent armour from WW was uncomfortable, they should have adjusted and padded to fit a little better. (Not that armour is always going to be comfortable *g*)
It's worth seeing if you want to see more of these characters. If you don't want to give Whedon any more money fair enough (I debated, but decided I wanted to see it, and it not completely Whedon and they have a good racial balance for a super hero team... and it gave me enough cinema points to get my ticket for double bill star wars free :D)
-
IN other news it's distinctly soggy. I had to use the motorway to get home (and that was SO much fun - random cone in the middle of the middle lane, just as entering roadworks were it went down to middle lane and flooded fast lane o.O - but the a road I normally use was flooded....it was generally a very interesting drive home)
I shall have to see if I can actually get to work tomorrow morning.....
I hope you are all well - and to those of you in my neck of the north western english woods, I hope you are as dry as you can be!
It's really strange, having The Orville and Discovery at the same time - like, the pilot for the Orville is a bit heavy and v sitcom-y and then literally the next episode they are into serious Star Trek like storylines, and like some heavy ones? The Orville is literally Star Trek: The Sitcom, or more accurately, Star Trek if it was real life. (Like TV military versus every story I have ever heard or experienced. (My great uncle is a now retired training officer in the RAF, Da was in the RAF, and I work in a museum that is part military. I have heard stories people)).
Discovery on the other hand, is Star Trek:Grey Area. On the subject of which, literally the next thing after my last Discovery post? That mid season finale....
Ok so - on the plus, Admiral didn't die! Wasn't dead. And she got to be awesome psych person (which feels a little bit like 'see this is what Deanna could have been' in some ways)
BUT STAMETS. *flails* - I saw it coming, from the semi bribery to effectively sacrifice himself for the scans (I half expected that whole conversation to be a weird half in Stamets head as he lay on a bio bed out of it version/POV of it) to oh look we showed you Lorca's screen and oh look Stamets is down.
I really really really hope he isn't dead. I really don't want ANOTHER kill all your gays storyline.
ESPECIALLY after we got the whole thing with Georgiou. Why? Because literally the three things that stood out in the pitch for this was: POC lead, Asian Woman Captain and Gay Character. We are already down Asian Woman Captain, and there's the dodgy, hopefully intential and to be dealt with thing that Lorca, white guy, is getting away with so much treason, while Michael, POC, is still being dragged for almost treasoning.
*sighs* It keeps having a built to being good, and then they throw in another 'look how messed up Lorca is!' moment.
And in other things, as kinda expected, the suspicions over Ash are likely correct (though the writers prob think they got that one past us) - I wasn't sure about the klingon disguised thing....but I was thrown by the 'hey I picked this guy up and now he's our new security chief!' thing. Though Lorca seems to just randomly adopt people he thinks are interesting so.....
Have to see how the back end of the series goes when it's back.
Non spoilery - I went to see Justice League - it's not bad. I still like Affleck's Batman. The others got a pretty good intro, but there was some weird bits (watch for Diana randomly changing from practical flat shoes to insane heels mid scene - and acquiring a sexy shawl, randomly) - but honestly? Not knowing what was changed by Whedon (though I would guess that extra sexy in scenes with Batman inconsistancies may be his addition) I don't know how much he changed the actual film.
It does work. It's an interesting story, it has pretty good pacing. It develops them all to an extent. It gives glimpses of things, and carries things to hint at links in and out (for solo films)
I could see bits that were v Joss and I could see gaps in the storytelling (I have seen enough Synder films to know his type of storytelling, and it had fragments of what he frames as key things, but others were left hanging a little).
The amazons costume change does not make sense at all (like one of the ladies who plays them was all 'you can see more of my muscles and it was more comfortable' and they argued some of it is ye olde amazons who didn't know how to make armour then, but seriously, I just went to a talk about the Scythians, and I studied Ancient Warfare, that be rubbish folks. Everyone has always been aware of what you need to protect. Plus the worst costumes were actually the modern ones (so 100 years AFTER we last saw them, they decided to reduce their armour, on the people who actually had the job that entails a threat *face palm*) To be honest, if the decent armour from WW was uncomfortable, they should have adjusted and padded to fit a little better. (Not that armour is always going to be comfortable *g*)
It's worth seeing if you want to see more of these characters. If you don't want to give Whedon any more money fair enough (I debated, but decided I wanted to see it, and it not completely Whedon and they have a good racial balance for a super hero team... and it gave me enough cinema points to get my ticket for double bill star wars free :D)
-
IN other news it's distinctly soggy. I had to use the motorway to get home (and that was SO much fun - random cone in the middle of the middle lane, just as entering roadworks were it went down to middle lane and flooded fast lane o.O - but the a road I normally use was flooded....it was generally a very interesting drive home)
I shall have to see if I can actually get to work tomorrow morning.....
I hope you are all well - and to those of you in my neck of the north western english woods, I hope you are as dry as you can be!
no subject
Ha, that's got to be the best description of the show I've seen so far. It's still on my to watch list (pilot felt a little too sitcomy?) but Discovery's also been feeling like it doesn't know if it wants to be Star Trek or Star Trek: Darker and Edgier.
Yeah, that Amazon costume change is...confusing in the counter arguments? Like hey, they discovered projectiles were a big problem, so you'd think they would try to keep covered up, if not upgrade into light metal armor? Or maybe leather/metal, instead of ditching pieces?
The general feeling I've been getting re JL is that it isn't bad, not as good as WW, but also not worth seeing more than once.
no subject
Yeah - Discovery briefly edged towards having found itself, but the mid season finale was them remembering they set out to be Darker and Edgier.
Yeah, given the amazons with the worst armour are the ones who had encountered bullets *face palm* But you got to see the crossfit woman's stomach and she's proud of that (that was what I got from her interview on it - which to be honest was entertainly like those male body builders who are all 'my muscles, do they impress you' so heh)
WW is by far the better film (the framing of things, and the general style, just worked in that film) - JL, I would watch again, though prob only once, depending on what happens in whatever DC does next.